A Service-First Approach to Insurance.

At Historic Square Agency, we create custom insurance solutions for our clients.

Get Quote

Insurance Agency in Erie, PA.

Simply put, all of us here at Historic Square Agency believe in looking out for our customers…like friends, like family. Our experience, dedication and our strong network of carriers allow us to deliver superior insurance services that make sense for each customer’s needs.

As your insurance advisor, we help you make smart decisions – protecting you from the unexpected and planning for the predictable.

Learn More About Our Agency
Read About Us
Get Quote

Personal Insurance

Insurance tailored to fit your life.

Learn More

Life Insurance

Protect what matters most.

Learn More

Business Insurance

Comprehensive coverage for your business.

Learn More

Matt was absolutely the most professional and knowledgeable Insurance Agent I have ever worked with. He asked me if he could review multiple policies I had in place and see if he could save me some money. I sent over two policies and within hours, he contacted me and said we should talk. As it turns out, Matt was able to save me over $300 a year AND with more coverage! The entire experience was extremely smooth and pleasant as well. I now have even more peace of mind and for less money. I 100% recommend Matt and even if you think you have the best rates out there, why not have him look at your policies too? It doesn’t cost you anything and you might end up saving...like me!

Dustin Whitney

Was a client for many years! Agents and staff are better at their jobs than I'd ever experienced in my previous half century of buying insurance for auto and home! I wish I had them here in Florida where I now reside! Historic Square is a remarkable credit to the fine reputation that Erie Insurance maintains!

Dennis King

Very easy to get a quote and questions are answered in a timely manner. HSA works hard to get you the best coverage they can in all necessary areas of life in addition to areas of coverage that are important to you. Very easy to work with! Highly recommended!

Laura Burkhardt

Mike and the HSA crew have been excellent. Throughout moving across state lines, buying multiple vehicles, purchasing a home, and filing various claims along the way - it has been a seamless process! On each policy, Mike has walked me through the details to be sure I understand the coverage I have and ensure I am comfortable. Additionally I like shopping for cars, and he is always quick to help me out with quotes during the process. I have recommended Mike and HSA to multiple friends and will continue to do so!

Brennan Donnelly

Very easy to work with. I greatly appreciated that Mike was able to do everything over the phone and email. It made things much easier. The online signing process from ERIE was also a breeze.

Corey Wilkosz

There's more to insurance than the price of the policy

Explore our interactive graphics and learn about your unique risks and the related insurance solutions.



Blog Article

January 2, 2018 in Personal Insurance

Life Insurance – So Much More Than a Death Benefit

What if I told you life insurance can be as versatile as a chameleon? But first, it’s important to understand the different types of life insurance. Broadly speaking, there are two options: term and permanent life insurance. Term policies provide a benefit if death occurs during a specified timeframe – often 10,…
Read More